: So, just what did I feel about "Return of the King?"
I could go on and on, but here's some excerpts from IMs I've been having:
WReality24: Just got back from "Return of the King"
ChazApe: What'd you think?
WReality24: One of the best movies I've ever seen
ChazApe: Heh.
ChazApe: It was definitely the best of the trilogy.
WReality24: I agree whole-heartedly.
WReality24: Just saw it . . .
FreshMarketMurph: amazing?
WReality24: Incredible
FreshMarketMurph: a few steps from perfection, i'd say
FreshMarketMurph: i would have only made a few changes
FreshMarketMurph: :-)
FreshMarketMurph: and, speaking of perfection, i start acme today... 7 am to 1
WReality24: yes, but only a few. "The Scouring of the Shire" being left out was my only complaint.
WReality24: Ahhh, good.
FreshMarketMurph: true... but that would have been a lot to add on to the film
FreshMarketMurph: i was saddened by no sauramin
FreshMarketMurph: and no lieutenant of mordor...
WReality24: Extended edition
FreshMarketMurph: it really needed some big guy up there to say "gandalf, you suck"
FreshMarketMurph: all mockingly.
WReality24: yes, the Mouth of Sauron was missed
FreshMarketMurph: but yes, the EE will fix that
FreshMarketMurph: though the true hero of the film is sam
FreshMarketMurph: he was incredible.
WReality24: Yes!
FreshMarketMurph: his one line really got me... "though i cannot carry your burden... i can carry you!"
FreshMarketMurph: the audience went nuts
WReality24: I found this movie the closets to Tolkien's vision
WReality24: Yes, as did ours
FreshMarketMurph: even though denthonir (spelling?) was a bit... um... lacking
FreshMarketMurph: he was still great with what he did
FreshMarketMurph: but i wish they developed him a little more
FreshMarketMurph: theodin was great... the charge really got me
WReality24: Yes it was.
FreshMarketMurph: and i wish they thew in some appendix stuff to the ending... like legolas and gimli going to the grey havens
FreshMarketMurph: (if i'm correct)
WReality24: Something like that.
FreshMarketMurph: i'm glad the movie ended with sam,t hough
FreshMarketMurph: *though
WReality24: Yes, with the exact liines from the book
WReality24: "well, i'm back"
FreshMarketMurph: but i would have liked to have seen merry, pippin, gimli and legolas go off too
FreshMarketMurph: they just kind of... walk away
FreshMarketMurph: the witch-king was cool 8-)
FreshMarketMurph: he didn't do much... but he was still cool
FreshMarketMurph: yeah minas morgul :-)
WReality24: Yeah, although I thought he had too many lines
FreshMarketMurph: true... but i was glad he at least did something more than scream
FreshMarketMurph: when he was fighting, he seemed huge
FreshMarketMurph: like, sauron-from-fellowship style
WReality24: Yes. I was on the edge of my seat during the battle of pellenor fields
WReality24: and in Mount Doom. It was done perfectly.
WReality24: Gollum's death was so grusome
FreshMarketMurph: likewise
FreshMarketMurph: mount doom, though a wee rushed in the end, was great
FreshMarketMurph: though i wish they would have done a mental "what i'm imagining" scene when sam held the ring
FreshMarketMurph: i would have loved to see jackson's vision of "Samwise the conqurer" or whatnot
WReality24: Yes, I always loved that scene from the book. Sam, sitting on his throne.
FreshMarketMurph: hehe
FreshMarketMurph: as he should!
FreshMarketMurph: though now i'm envisioning dan mcpeek wearing the witch-king's helmet
WReality24: lol
FreshMarketMurph: "no customer can kill me!"
FreshMarketMurph: "i am no customer!"
FreshMarketMurph: hah!
FreshMarketMurph: lol
WReality24: lol
FreshMarketMurph: the endings were beautiful though
FreshMarketMurph: i always get choked up with elrond and arawen
FreshMarketMurph: he looked like he was about to cry there too
FreshMarketMurph: so good
FreshMarketMurph: i really want to see this movie again so i can appreciate it, rather than being on the edge of my seat :-)
WReality24: the Arwen stuff didn't have much effect on me. The Gray Havens scene had me teary-eyed.
WReality24: yeah, same here.
FreshMarketMurph: eh, i always get chokey when they chat about elrond giving arawen awy
FreshMarketMurph: *away
FreshMarketMurph: heck, i was sad when haldir died
FreshMarketMurph: he always ruled.
FreshMarketMurph: and olephants are just cool
FreshMarketMurph: and i learned that charging them on horseback is a bad idea.
WReality24: Yeah. As soon as I saw that, I just knew the ol' Riders of Rohan were in for trouble.
FreshMarketMurph: i liked merry and pippin... they really developed as more than "comic relief"
WReality24: The Armies of Dead was an incredible visual
FreshMarketMurph: and gimli was actually funnier
FreshMarketMurph: oh yes... the audience went nuts when they poured out of the ships.
WReality24: Glad you had quite the active crowd. Ours was as well.
FreshMarketMurph: i did the trilogy tuesday thing
FreshMarketMurph: so everybody was gripping their seats
WReality24: I heard about that from Danny.
FreshMarketMurph: my eyes are still a wee bit sore from all that movie watching
FreshMarketMurph: at the end of ROTK, i thought i was going to die
WReality24: Trish and I were going to watch the two other before we went, but we ran outta time.
FreshMarketMurph: 12 hours or so of watching
FreshMarketMurph: and nearly 17 hours spent at tinsteltown
FreshMarketMurph: yeah obsession >:o
WReality24: I wanted to do that, but I don't think I would have been able to handle it.
FreshMarketMurph: it was quite a test of endurance
FreshMarketMurph: i thought i was going to kill myself during fellowship
FreshMarketMurph: i enjoy it... but i just watched it a week or so ago
FreshMarketMurph: that's a lot of introduction
WReality24: Indeed. It's hard to get through, esspecially the EE.
FreshMarketMurph: the two towers EE is quite enjoyable
FreshMarketMurph: i prefer that ending
WReality24: with Fangorn Forest? Yes.
FreshMarketMurph: ROTK's extended should be at least 4 hours long, i'm told
FreshMarketMurph: 4.25, if possible
WReality24: I plan on sitting down and watching all three EE's when ROTK comes out.
FreshMarketMurph: better get some caffine for that :-)
WReality24: Planning on it.
Spot0: But how was the movie?
WReality24: One of the best movies I've ever seen, to be honest.
Spot0: Really?
WReality24: Yeah. It hit on every level. It had it's minor flaws, but overall very, very good. Any big problems should be rolled in the "Extended Edition" next year on DVD.
Spot0: How long was the movie overall?
WReality24: 3 hours, 40 minutes
WReality24: I think I need to see it again, though, to soak it all in. This first was very much a heart-pounding, edge of seat viewing. The second time, I can really get a better feel for it.
WReality24: If that makes any sense at all . . .
Spot0: I hear the epic final battle is a lot like Two Towers.
WReality24: To an extent. Somethings are pretty similair, but there are more differences that similairites.
Spot0: Hrm... I'll have to see it, I guess.
So . . . what's that tell you?
~W~
I could go on and on, but here's some excerpts from IMs I've been having:
WReality24: Just got back from "Return of the King"
ChazApe: What'd you think?
WReality24: One of the best movies I've ever seen
ChazApe: Heh.
ChazApe: It was definitely the best of the trilogy.
WReality24: I agree whole-heartedly.
WReality24: Just saw it . . .
FreshMarketMurph: amazing?
WReality24: Incredible
FreshMarketMurph: a few steps from perfection, i'd say
FreshMarketMurph: i would have only made a few changes
FreshMarketMurph: :-)
FreshMarketMurph: and, speaking of perfection, i start acme today... 7 am to 1
WReality24: yes, but only a few. "The Scouring of the Shire" being left out was my only complaint.
WReality24: Ahhh, good.
FreshMarketMurph: true... but that would have been a lot to add on to the film
FreshMarketMurph: i was saddened by no sauramin
FreshMarketMurph: and no lieutenant of mordor...
WReality24: Extended edition
FreshMarketMurph: it really needed some big guy up there to say "gandalf, you suck"
FreshMarketMurph: all mockingly.
WReality24: yes, the Mouth of Sauron was missed
FreshMarketMurph: but yes, the EE will fix that
FreshMarketMurph: though the true hero of the film is sam
FreshMarketMurph: he was incredible.
WReality24: Yes!
FreshMarketMurph: his one line really got me... "though i cannot carry your burden... i can carry you!"
FreshMarketMurph: the audience went nuts
WReality24: I found this movie the closets to Tolkien's vision
WReality24: Yes, as did ours
FreshMarketMurph: even though denthonir (spelling?) was a bit... um... lacking
FreshMarketMurph: he was still great with what he did
FreshMarketMurph: but i wish they developed him a little more
FreshMarketMurph: theodin was great... the charge really got me
WReality24: Yes it was.
FreshMarketMurph: and i wish they thew in some appendix stuff to the ending... like legolas and gimli going to the grey havens
FreshMarketMurph: (if i'm correct)
WReality24: Something like that.
FreshMarketMurph: i'm glad the movie ended with sam,t hough
FreshMarketMurph: *though
WReality24: Yes, with the exact liines from the book
WReality24: "well, i'm back"
FreshMarketMurph: but i would have liked to have seen merry, pippin, gimli and legolas go off too
FreshMarketMurph: they just kind of... walk away
FreshMarketMurph: the witch-king was cool 8-)
FreshMarketMurph: he didn't do much... but he was still cool
FreshMarketMurph: yeah minas morgul :-)
WReality24: Yeah, although I thought he had too many lines
FreshMarketMurph: true... but i was glad he at least did something more than scream
FreshMarketMurph: when he was fighting, he seemed huge
FreshMarketMurph: like, sauron-from-fellowship style
WReality24: Yes. I was on the edge of my seat during the battle of pellenor fields
WReality24: and in Mount Doom. It was done perfectly.
WReality24: Gollum's death was so grusome
FreshMarketMurph: likewise
FreshMarketMurph: mount doom, though a wee rushed in the end, was great
FreshMarketMurph: though i wish they would have done a mental "what i'm imagining" scene when sam held the ring
FreshMarketMurph: i would have loved to see jackson's vision of "Samwise the conqurer" or whatnot
WReality24: Yes, I always loved that scene from the book. Sam, sitting on his throne.
FreshMarketMurph: hehe
FreshMarketMurph: as he should!
FreshMarketMurph: though now i'm envisioning dan mcpeek wearing the witch-king's helmet
WReality24: lol
FreshMarketMurph: "no customer can kill me!"
FreshMarketMurph: "i am no customer!"
FreshMarketMurph: hah!
FreshMarketMurph: lol
WReality24: lol
FreshMarketMurph: the endings were beautiful though
FreshMarketMurph: i always get choked up with elrond and arawen
FreshMarketMurph: he looked like he was about to cry there too
FreshMarketMurph: so good
FreshMarketMurph: i really want to see this movie again so i can appreciate it, rather than being on the edge of my seat :-)
WReality24: the Arwen stuff didn't have much effect on me. The Gray Havens scene had me teary-eyed.
WReality24: yeah, same here.
FreshMarketMurph: eh, i always get chokey when they chat about elrond giving arawen awy
FreshMarketMurph: *away
FreshMarketMurph: heck, i was sad when haldir died
FreshMarketMurph: he always ruled.
FreshMarketMurph: and olephants are just cool
FreshMarketMurph: and i learned that charging them on horseback is a bad idea.
WReality24: Yeah. As soon as I saw that, I just knew the ol' Riders of Rohan were in for trouble.
FreshMarketMurph: i liked merry and pippin... they really developed as more than "comic relief"
WReality24: The Armies of Dead was an incredible visual
FreshMarketMurph: and gimli was actually funnier
FreshMarketMurph: oh yes... the audience went nuts when they poured out of the ships.
WReality24: Glad you had quite the active crowd. Ours was as well.
FreshMarketMurph: i did the trilogy tuesday thing
FreshMarketMurph: so everybody was gripping their seats
WReality24: I heard about that from Danny.
FreshMarketMurph: my eyes are still a wee bit sore from all that movie watching
FreshMarketMurph: at the end of ROTK, i thought i was going to die
WReality24: Trish and I were going to watch the two other before we went, but we ran outta time.
FreshMarketMurph: 12 hours or so of watching
FreshMarketMurph: and nearly 17 hours spent at tinsteltown
FreshMarketMurph: yeah obsession >:o
WReality24: I wanted to do that, but I don't think I would have been able to handle it.
FreshMarketMurph: it was quite a test of endurance
FreshMarketMurph: i thought i was going to kill myself during fellowship
FreshMarketMurph: i enjoy it... but i just watched it a week or so ago
FreshMarketMurph: that's a lot of introduction
WReality24: Indeed. It's hard to get through, esspecially the EE.
FreshMarketMurph: the two towers EE is quite enjoyable
FreshMarketMurph: i prefer that ending
WReality24: with Fangorn Forest? Yes.
FreshMarketMurph: ROTK's extended should be at least 4 hours long, i'm told
FreshMarketMurph: 4.25, if possible
WReality24: I plan on sitting down and watching all three EE's when ROTK comes out.
FreshMarketMurph: better get some caffine for that :-)
WReality24: Planning on it.
Spot0: But how was the movie?
WReality24: One of the best movies I've ever seen, to be honest.
Spot0: Really?
WReality24: Yeah. It hit on every level. It had it's minor flaws, but overall very, very good. Any big problems should be rolled in the "Extended Edition" next year on DVD.
Spot0: How long was the movie overall?
WReality24: 3 hours, 40 minutes
WReality24: I think I need to see it again, though, to soak it all in. This first was very much a heart-pounding, edge of seat viewing. The second time, I can really get a better feel for it.
WReality24: If that makes any sense at all . . .
Spot0: I hear the epic final battle is a lot like Two Towers.
WReality24: To an extent. Somethings are pretty similair, but there are more differences that similairites.
Spot0: Hrm... I'll have to see it, I guess.
So . . . what's that tell you?
~W~
Current Mood:
chipper