Chiriko's Blurty Entries [entries|friends|calendar]
Chiriko

[ userinfo | blurty userinfo ]
[ calendar | blurty calendar ]

Takamatsu Zuka Kofun Controversy [09 Apr 2003|08:00pm]
[ mood | accomplished ]
[ music | 1/3 Junjou na Kanjou ~ Siam Shade ]

Konban wa, Minna-San! I'm posting two things today so I can get this on a roll. I'm almost finished! *Cheers* I hope that all of this has been as exciting for you as it has been for me!

-Chiriko
--------------------------------------------------

Takamatsu Zuka Kofun
The Controversy Continues


By Steve Renshaw
Supplement to Takamatsu Zuka Kofun, added April, 1997




What is so significant about Takamatsu Zuka Kofun is the fact that it clearly shows the influence of Chinese and Korean astrology and divination on Japan in the Asuka Era. The discovery of the tomb created much excitement throughout Japan in 1972, and a panel of Japanese archaeologists and historians held a symposium in Asuka Village on March 21, 1997 to commemorate the 25th anniversary of the tomb's discovery. At issue were the same controversial questions which have been raised since its discovery in 1972:
1. When exactly was the tomb constructed?
2. Who was buried in the tomb?

The significance and implication of answers to these questions basically concern determination of the tomb's "place" within a period of great change in Japan. The Asuka Era was a period in which the great "key hole" shaped tombs with their array of "Haniwa" pottery gave way to much smaller and decorative construction. It was a time of both positive and negative interaction with China and Korea. It was also a period in which power became centralized in the Yamato plain partly due to the regulation of rice cultivation and also to the use of social techniques to balance an infusion of Buddhist and Confucian principles with the more native "gods" and practices of Shinto. Archaeoastronomically, it is in this period that one can see an almost haphazard north-south alignment of tombs and other structures in the Asuka area of the Yamato plain give way to more precise geomancy, readily evident as one moves historically forward in time and geographically further north toward Nara and Kyoto. Significantly, the "inhabitant" of Takamatsu Zuka Kofun was placed within a "universe" which reflected a Chinese infused "cosmology" and myth precisely linking heaven with earth. If the tomb's occupant were of imperial or at least Japanese lineage, this would provide evidence that such a "cosmology" may have been accepted and relatively firmly in place in Japan at the time of the tomb's construction. On the other hand, if the occupant were an envoy or "exchange" scholar from China or Korea, such a "cosmology" might only have been the "universe" of this one "foreign" individual.

In short, symposium participants sought answers to questions which could provide additional evidence for understanding the transformation which occurred when "foreign" ideas and technology became part of the Japanese "psyche", a transformation that led to a huge "burst" of unique and creative adaptation of Chinese principles so evident in the later Nara and Heian eras of Japan. Unfortunately, the panel of scholars did little to resolve questions. If anything, they showed that the list of "candidates" for the tomb's occupant has grown rather than shrunk in the past 25 years (now to over 50). With regard to the date of the tomb's construction, research was reported regarding the tomb painter's use of white lead based pigment; analysis of similarity between the tomb's decorative metal fittings and artifacts found at the San Gatsu Dou (March Hall) in Nara's Todaiji temple complex was also presented. Both reports tend to give weight to a post-700 A.D. date for the tomb's construction. However, it was pointed out by one historian that the occupant was not cremated but rather buried "full body", a fact which he claimed supported a pre-700 A.D. date for the tomb's construction. [Given the variety of contemporaneous practices in China and Korea, I'm not sure this burial "behavior" would necessarily preclude a later date even though cremation and use of much smaller tombs for "royalty" did become the more common practice in early 8th century Japan]. At any rate, definitive answers regarding the tomb's occupant and date seem somewhat more elusive now than they did 25 years ago, even given the additional accumulation of "evidence".

There are other mounds in the Kinki area which, if excavated, might shed more light on questions and issues related to Takamatsu Zuka Kofun. Unfortunately, archaeological investigation in Japan is a somewhat complex matter. While it was reported in 1996 that fiber optic probes indicate that a similar tomb with similar paintings may be nearby, archaeologists are awaiting purchase by the city of Asuka from the land's present owner before excavation can begin.

Such complication is true of many sites in Japan. Several ancient tombs remain untouched because they are still considered to be under the sacred protection of the imperial family. Other intact sites, some of which may have significant archaeoastronomical impact, remain unexcavated because archaeologists are now having to spend virtually every resource rescuing less archaeologically rich but nonetheless valuable sites from highway and urban development (up to 1000 "rescues" per year as reported in archaeological literature). They do this in hopes that the perhaps richer intact sites will remain for future exploration.
2 Miracles:: A Shooting Star!

Takamatsu Zuka Kofun in Asuka [07 Apr 2003|03:35pm]
[ mood | happy ]
[ music | Akemi Satou - Shiawase ni Narou ne ]

Takamatsu Zuka Kofun
An Ancient View of the Sky from a Tomb in Asuka, Japan


By Steve Renshaw and Saori Ihara

April, 1996

[This article also appears in Startimes, April, 1996.]




A primary center of power in Japan in the 6th and 7th centuries, Asuka Village lies about 12 miles south of Nara in the Kinki District. The modern traveller to the area is quickly struck by the mix of urban sprawl and ancient temples and tombs. It was in one of these tombs that a major archaeological discovery was made in the early 1970's. From an Edo Era painting showing the mound with a tall pine tree atop, the tomb was called Takamatsu Zuka Kofun (Tall Pine Ancient Burial Mound).



Takamatsu Zuka Kofun is aligned with celestial north. This view from due south shows the bamboo covered mound of the tomb. The doors are to chambers of relatively recent origin; inside are housed temperature maintenance and dehumidifying equipment used to protect the small tomb's delicate paintings.

Dating indicates that the tomb was built in the latter part of the 7th or early part of the 8th century. It measures 1 meter wide, 2.7 meters deep, and a little more than a meter high. In these rather cramped "quarters", archaeologists found a little universe. Even in death, the tomb's "resident" could "see" and be a part of the heavenly realm.

Inside the tomb, on the East wall, the sun was painted in gold leaf; on the west wall, the moon appeared in silver. Also adorning the walls were male servants and female consorts in dress of the era still there to provide for the deceased.



As was and is the case with most burials in China, Korea, and Japan, the tomb was aligned with the cardinal directions. Gods of these four directions, whose Chinese origins are somewhat lost in obscurity, were also found on the walls in complementary configuration: the Black Tortoise of the North, the Azure Dragon of the East, and the White Tiger of the West. Intrusion through the south wall some time after the tomb was built had obliterated what was probably the Pheonix of Summer.



Facing North inside Takamatsu Zuka Kofun with "Genbu" (The Black Tortoise of Winter) painted on the wall.

Careful inspection of the ceiling revealed a series of dots, also in gold leaf, each about a centimeter in diameter. The dots were in clusters connected by red lines.



In the middle was "Shibien", the North Pole, with what was known to ancient Chinese as the "Purple Palace". This association consists of the crosspiece (Alpha UMi, "Center of the Heavens"), the emperor (5 UMi), the empress (FGW Struve 1694), the crown prince (Beta UMi), and the bastard child (4 UMi). Also present were the four protecting ministers (51H Cep, 2 Cep, 39H Cep, and a still unknown corresponding star). Circling this realm of "Tentei" (emperor) were the 28 "shuku" (moon "mansions") in a more or less ecliptic hugging arrangement similar to that known in China more than 2000 years before the tomb was made



Moon Stations with lines connecting stars can be seen on the ceiling of Takamatsu Zuka Kofun

As the name implies, "shuku" were associations of stars where the moon was said to reside each night in its trip around the earth. Each shuku had a reference star through which imaginary lines from north to south poles could be drawn to delineate areas of the sky. Used in astrology and divination, the "shuku" were divided into four groups of seven, each group corresponding to one of the four cardinal directions. Though the particular stars chosen for both reference and associations within "shuku" underwent minor change, most retained a relatively consistent form through dynastic upheaval and diffusion to Korea and Japan. They were as familiar to Asian astrologers as zodiacal signs were (and are) to Western counterparts. Such were the "shuku" found in Takamatsu Zuka Kofun.

Moving around the ceiling, from east to north to west to south, familiar patterns emerge to Western eyes. In the East Palace of the Azure Dragon, portions of Virgo, Libra, Scorpio and Sagittarius can be seen. Moving to the North Palace of the Black Tortoise, the eastern "dipper" of the Sagittarius teapot is easily visualized followed by portions of Capricorn and Aquarius. The last two stations of the North are recognizable as the square of Pegasus. In the West Palace of the White Tiger, a "slipper" can be seen made from stars of Andromeda and including M31. Moving past two stations in Aries, the next "shuku" are respectively the easily recognizable Pleiades, Hyades, Maissa, and stars centered around Orion's belt.

The intrusion which destroyed what was probably the Red Bird of the South also obliterated much of the "shuku" related to that direction. Still, one can see bits of the seven stations. Completing the circle are a "well" made of the "lower" portion of Gemini followed by associations in Cancer, Hydra, Crater, and Corvus.

Mystery still surrounds Takamatsu Zuka Kofun [see The Controversy Continues]. Only a few scholars knew of the tomb's existence in the Edo era (1603-1867), and most believed it was that of the emperor Monbu. Modern excavation revealed no inscription, and Monbu's tomb was later determined to be to the East. Tombs similar to "Tall Pine Ancient Burial Mound" have been found in both China and Korea, and the period in which the tomb was constructed was also one in which scholars from Korea had been invited to the royal court. Who was buried in Takamatsu Zuka Kofun? Was it an emperor or royal prince? Or could it have been someone else, perhaps a scholar or "astronomer" from Korea spurning a return to turmoil in his own country and finding a new home in Japan, that was given this "celestial" burial?

Regardless of who was buried there, Takamatsu Zuka Kofun is one of the few known sites in Japan with a record of ancient views of the heavens. While the tomb is sealed from public view, full scale models with remarkable fidelity can be seen and "crawled through" in the museum near the tomb's Asuka site as well as the Nara Exhibition Hall for History which is located above Kintetsu station in that city.
A Shooting Star!

The Pheonix (Suzaku) of the South (Summer) [07 Apr 2003|01:00am]
[ mood | accomplished ]
[ music | Winner - Fushigi Yuugi -Akemi Saito -Insert Song ]

Here we go! The Suzaku constellations! ^^ Finally done with these. I hope you all enjoy them!

~Chiriko
--------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Pheonix (Suzaku) of the South (Summer)



The 7 Moon Stations of the "South", "Suzaku", or "Red Bird"
Moon Stations are connected by red lines. Key stars are circled in yellow




Moon Statiosn of "Suzaku" (The Red Bird/Pheonix)

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: ChichiriBoshi
Meaning = Well
Key Star: Mu Gem

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: TamahomeBoshi
Meaning = Ogre, Devil perhaps Ghost
Key Star: Delta Cnc; sometimes Theta Cnc

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: NurikoBoshi
Meaning = Willow
Key Star: Delta Hya

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: HotohoriBoshi
Meaning = Stars
Key Star: Alpha Hya

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: ChirikoBoshi
Meaning = Stretched Net
Key Star: Nu Hya

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: TasukiBoshi
Meaning = Wings
Key Star: Alpha Crt

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: MitsukakeBoshi
Meaning = Chariot Cross-board, perhaps strings of Koto
Key Star: Gamma Crv





Simulation using The Sky showing Summer Solstice around 500 B.C. Note that the sun is indeed "moving" within the moon stations of the Red Bird of Summer, and the handle of the big dipper ("North Seven Stars") seen at sunset is pointed upward or South.
2 Miracles:: A Shooting Star!

The Byakko ("White Tiger") of the West (Fall) [06 Apr 2003|09:50pm]
[ mood | accomplished ]
[ music | To the Moon and Back - Savage Garden ]

Konban Wa, Minna-San!

I'm sorry for not being around for the past few days. I've been quite busy studying and working hard for some tests. I've some more information to post now. This time it's for Byakko. Seeing as I've missed the past few days of posting, I'll also post up Suzakus tonight as well! Keep your eyes out!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The "Byakko" (White Tiger) of the West (Fall)



Drawing Based on Byakko (White Tiger) Found at Takamatsu Zuka Kofun



The 7 Moon Stations of "Byakko", the "West" or "White Tiger"

Moon Stations are connected by red lines. Key stars are circled in yellow




Moon Stations of the "Byakko" (White Tiger)

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: TokakiBoshi
Meaning = Stride, Foot
Key Star: Delta And

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: TataraBoshi
Meaning = Hill, Lasso; Perhaps Bellows
Key Star: Beta Ari

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: EkieBoshi
Meaning = Stomach
Key Star: 35 Ari

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: SubaruBoshi
Meaning = Stopping Place, United; perhaps "Getting Together"
Key Star: 17 Tau; sometimes 16 Tau

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: AmefuriBoshi
Meaning = Net; perhaps related to Rain
Key Star: Epsilon Tau

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: TorokiBoshi
Meaning = Turtle Snout, perhaps Tuft on Owl's Head
Key Star: Lamda Ori; sometimes Phi Ori

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: KagasukiBoshi
Meaning = Investigator, Three
Key Star: Delta Ori; sometimes Beta Ori






Simulation using The Sky showing Spring Equinox around 500 B.C. Note that while the sun is "moving" within the moon stations of the White Tiger, the handle of the big dipper ("North Seven Stars") seen at sunset is pointed toward the East, ruled by the Azure or Blue Dragon of Spring.
A Shooting Star!

The "Genbu" (Black Tortoise) of the North (Winter) [01 Apr 2003|05:04pm]
[ mood | accomplished ]
[ music | Voice - Tamahome - Fushigi Yuugi ]

Konnichi Wa, Minna-San!

Chiriko here with more information on the beast gods! This time it's about Genbu! I hope I'm not boring any of you with my posts. I instead hope that these are striking some intrest up in all of you, Or at least hope you think it's neat. ^-^ If they are boring you, I'm most sorry! Gomen. *bows*
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The "Genbu" (Black Tortoise) of the North (Winter)


Drawing Based on Genbu Found at Takamatsu Zuka Kofun


The 7 Moon Stations of the "North" (Genbu) or "Black Tortoise of Winter" (also "Somber" or "Black" Warrior)

Moon Stations are connected by red lines. Key stars are circled in yellow.




Moon Stations of the "Black Tortoise"

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: HikitsuBoshi
Meaning = Dipper; Measure
Key Star: Phi Sgr

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: InamiBoshi
Meaning = Cow
Key Star: Beta Cap

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: UrukiBoshi
Meaning = Woman; Perhaps waiting Maid
Key Star: Epsilon Aqr

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: TomiteBoshi
Meaning = Emptiness
Key Star: Beta Aqr

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: UmiyameBoshi
Meaning = Roof Top, Perhaps Danger, Steep
Key Star: Alpha Aqr

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: Hatsui
Meaning = Room, perhaps Encampment
Key Star: Alpha Peg

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: NamameBoshi
Meaning = Wall
Key Star: Gamma Peg





Simulation using The Sky showing Summer Solstice around 500 B.C. Note that the sun is indeed "moving" within the moon stations of Genbu or the Black Tortoise of Winter, and the handle of the big dipper ("North Seven Stars") seen at sunset is pointed downward or North.
1 Miracle:: A Shooting Star!

The "Seiryuu" (Azure Dragon) of the East (Spring) [31 Mar 2003|04:25pm]
[ mood | accomplished ]
[ music | Akai Iitsutae - Chiriko, Fushigi Yuugi ]

Konnichi Wa, Minna-San! Now i am posting information on the Dragon of the East. More Chinese Star knowledge! ^.^
---------------------------------------------------

The "Seiryuu" (Azure Dragon) of the East (Spring)


Drawing based on "Seiryuu" (Azure Dragon) found at Takamatsu Zuka Kofun


The 7 Moon Stations of the "East" or "Blue Dragon"

Moon Stations are connected by red lines. Key stars are circled in yellow




Moon Stations of the Azure Dragon

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: SuBoshi
Meaning = Horn(s), perhaps Angle, Corner
Key Star: Alpha Vir

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: AmiBoshi
Meaning = Neck, Throat
Key Star: Kappa Vir

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: TomoBoshi
Meaning = Root, perhaps Shoulder or Base
Key Star: Iota Lib, sometimes Alpha Lib

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: SoiBoshi
Meaning = Chamber, Perhaps Breasts
Key Star: Delta Sco; Sometimes, Pi Sco

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: NakagoBoshi
Meaning = Heart
Key Star: Sigma Sco

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: AshitareBoshi
Meaning = Tail
Key Star: Mu Sco

Chinese Character

Japanese Name: MiBoshi
Meaning = Basket
Key Star: Gama Sgr; Sometimes, Eta Sgr




Simulation using The Sky showing Autumn Equinox around 500 B.C. Note that while the sun is "moving" within the moon stations of the Azure Dragon, the handle of the big dipper ("North Seven Stars") seen at sunset is pointed toward the West, ruled by the White Tiger of Autumn.
1 Miracle:: A Shooting Star!

Konban Wa! [30 Mar 2003|08:25pm]
[ mood | excited ]
[ music | Star ~ Akemi Saito ]

Good Evening, Minna-San! ^-^

Tonight I start out with Chinese Astrology!
-------------------------------------------------------------

Until the Meiji Restoration, charting of the heavens in Japan (like most astronomical observation) was closely tied to divination and calendar reckoning for astrological purposes. While there were some variations in choice of stars, delineation of asterisms by Japanese chart makers closely followed traditions and developments in China. For ancient Chinese and later Korean and Japanese cartographers, four talismanic animals marked the four seasons and four cardinal directions...the Azure Dragon of the East (Spring), the Red Bird of the South (Summer), the White Tiger of the West (Fall), and the "Genbu" (Black Tortoise) of the North (Winter) [actually there were five, the other "direction" being "center" Earth!]. Corresponding to each of the celestial "palaces" were seven "stations" of the moon. Moon "stations" or "lodges" were of course, based on the daily and nightly position of the moon among the stars. Origins of these associations are somewhat obscure and even controversial. In China, they appear to be at least 3500 years old, some estimates dating much earlier. In Japan, their first confirmed "existence" is found in the 7th century (probable dating) Takamatsu Zuka Kofun (Pine Tree Burial Mound) and the recently explored Kitora Tomb.
((Chiriko: Amazing Isn't it??))

Determination of the talismanic animals and associated star "palaces" together with the associated 28 sei shuku or moon stations, represent some of the most complex aspects of Asian "astronomy". The associations have not only been adapted over the centuries but are also tied to the astrology of each culture. Cultures using these associations were/are located in the Northern hemisphere for the most part. An apparent anomalie is the fact that the actual positional path of the sun seems to move in a direction opposite the seasonal associations of Spring and Fall. While "Genbu" (translated as the black tortoise of winter, a name which fails to really convey the fearsome nature of this snakelike shelled "creature" or "god") and the red bird of summer have the sun nicely positioned in them during their respective seasons, the white tiger of autumn and blue dragon of spring lie "opposite" the sun's actual perceived path. While Staal (1984) argues that this is due to the animals and moon stations being created some 17 to 18 millennia ago (precession creating the anomaly), there is actually little archaeological and certainly no written evidence to indicate that this kind of system was in use at such an early time (Although there have been markings found recently! ~Kitora Tomb!~); this also does not really explain the apparent "backward" motion of the sun through seasons. More likely, moon stations may have been among the first delineated constellations and were perhaps used as markers for seasonal change; they were subsequently incorporated into a more complex mathematical division of the "heavens" (months, principle and sectional terms, etc.). They quite possibly were used in conjunction with the direction to which the handle of the big dipper (often called the "North Seven Stars" in China, Korea, and Japan) pointed at the equinoxes and solstices. In other words, the "North Seven Stars" were probably used as an actual "time piece" for determination of season. Before the Christian Era, when the sei shuku were created, the "North Seven Stars" did not appear to "set" (with precession, they had a relatively "higher" position than now). Thus, they could be seen and used in conjunction with the sei shuku as such a seasonal "time piece" year round (see Yoke, 1985, for further explanation in English). Looking toward the North, the handle of the "North Seven Stars", when viewed each evening at an ideal time, appeared to rotate in a counterclockwise manner through the year, apparently in opposite direction to the sun's movement through the ecliptic and moon stations. The reader may find some visual explanation of this anomaly by looking at the charts accompanying the links to seasonal animals. (I'll have this up soon) At any rate, with precession, their function probably took on more and more of an astrological function as centuries progressed, and this was certainly their primary "function" as they found their way to Japan in the early centuries A.D. (see Nivison's 1989 article for an excellent discussion in English of various aspects and "problems" related to the origin and development of the sei shuku).

In many ways, these associations reflect the Kagami/mirror or "shadow" relation of earth to sky... human to nature... nature to cosmos... that was so prominent in pre-scientific cosmologies in this part of Asia. At times we are looking at earth from the perspective of the emperor; that is, we are in the North, South is opposite, East is to the left, and West is to the right. At other times, we are looking toward the North, from the earth, and reading the signs of stars relative to our previously defined "earthly" directions.

Like myths and traditions in Western cultures, these views still wield influence in the daily life of people in China, Korea, and Japan... this despite quite prominent scientific literacy. However, it should be pointed out that astrological divination in China, Korea and Japan was, and is, rather complex. It took and still takes into account many "elements" of sky and earth, an elaborate geomancy including but certainly not limited to the position of some celestial body within a given constellation at a person's birth. It is difficult to argue that the system is not intellectually rich, and it no doubt had pragmatic use in both affairs of state and "common" person. However, it is somewhat sad that in the long history of China, not to mention the curious but rather isolated Japan, such concentration on astrological matters held attention much longer than in the West, thus retarding at times significant scientific advances in astronomy (see Calendar Reform in Japan).

That said, lore related to moon stations is one of the most interesting aspects of Asian Ethnoastronomy. Somewhat similar to Chinese but perhaps even more, Japanese interpretations of these associations tended to revolve around agricultural needs and animistic views of nature. Unlike many Western myths and traditions, there were few if any perceptions in the myths of "active" god(s) creating or wreaking good or bad on the cosmos and/or humankind. Rather, especially in Japan with its Shinto base, gods like the talismanic animals were seen as manifestations of nature... stars and celestial events were signs of change in season, life, politics, etc... perhaps most often portending "bad" but sometimes "good" as well.

Below is an example of a star chart from Edo Era Japan.


A 1699 Star Chart by Harumi Yasui


Close-Up of Yasui's Map Showing the First 15 Moon Stations

The "KyoSei" or key star for each Moon Station is circled in red. The key star for Station 1 is Alpha Vir (Spica).

Readers who are interested in more information in English about origins as well as views of all Chinese constellations associated with the segments of moon stations might want to look at the Nivison work referenced above and the work of Yoke (1985). While Staal (1984) does an admirable job of relating Chinese constellation lore, his speculations and interpretations should be viewed cautiously, especially with regard to origin and meaning of Chinese characters.

7 Miracles:: A Shooting Star!

navigation
[ viewing | most recent entries ]